Proof of heaven is a compelling story of what may lie ahead for all of us in the life beyond this one. Luke dittrich, contributing editor at esquire, wrote an article critical of dr. Esquire unearths proof of heaven authors credibility problems. Hamilton, md, facs, author of the scalpel and the soul and zen mind, zen horse i can highly recommend this important book that. Dittrich cited several malpractice lawsuits against. Proof of heaven quotes showing of 110 communicating with god is the most extraordinary experience imaginable, yet at the same time its the most natural one. Eben alexanders book proof of heaven is proof of hallucination, not heaven, according to michael shermer at scientific american, in a hilarious comment thats adding to the criticism of this interesting publishing phenomenon. Miller join skeptiko host alex tsakiris for an interview with robert mays about his recently published article, esquire article on eben alexander distorts the facts. Alexander is also the author of the 2014 book the map. I dont see any reason that a surgeon who knows how to operate on brains would have any special authority to write on the existence of an afterlife. Alexanders story, he found many unexpected discrepancies one such example is that dr. Journalist questions the book proof of heaven inside. I wrote a truthful account of my experiences in proof of heaven and have acknowledged in the book both my professional and.
He wrote about his experiences in his book, proof of heaven, published october 2012. A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife reprint by alexander, eben isbn. Has anyone here read proof of heaven by eben alexander. Believers need not read this book for it says nothing new insofar as the prevalent belief system about the afterlife is. Eben alexander iii born december 11, 1953 is an american neurosurgeon and author. Thanks to commenter mitil for providing me with the link. Eben alexanders book, proof of heaven, which has sold 2 million copies. Proof of heaven claims questioned in new report share or comment on this article. His story is now detailed in the book proof of heaven, first published in 2012. Alexander, in some of which the allegation was that alexander had altered medical records to cover his errors. Well, it turns out that my skepticism about eben alexanders socalled proof of heaven title of the book he wrote was wellfounded. The proof of heaven author has now been thoroughly debunked by science. A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife, which was released in october 2012, featured on dr.
In 2008, a neurosurgeon named eben alexander slipped into a coma while being treated in er. It covers the major allegations made against alexander, including the claims that he was not in a real coma, that his condition was not as serious as. Proof of heaven has sold more than 2 million copies, and turned dr. Disproof of eben alexanders proof of heaven maverick. Doctor who penned bestseller proof of heaven under fire for false claims. Proof of heaven author has multiple claims from his book.
Alexander asks esquire s dittrich not to bring up the. I cannot speak for anyone else, but here are my thoughts its an interesting claim, for sure. The science of the neardeath experience proof of heaven is more than just an aweinspiring account of a profound encounter with spiritual reality. Every product was carefully curated by an esquire editor. In proof of hea ven, alexander writes that he spent seven days in a coma caused by a rare case of e. This compelling and heartfelt novel will appeal to readers of all beliefs and backgrounds. Proof of heaven is the story of a neurosurgeons neardeath experience and what he says was his journey to heaven. Luke dittrich, contributing editor at esquire, wrote.
The book documents alexanders experience of a near death experience after suffering from a bacterial meningitis induced coma. A book called proof of heaven is bound to provoke eye rolls. The previous mentioned books, heaven is for real, and proof of heaven, though wellwritten, and seemingly wellintentioned, i have a lot of problems with. Eben alexander should visit pampanga, philippines one day and surprise himself that the kapampangans pronounce heaven and his first name almost the same way. Last week an article was brought to my attention by ester zuckerman in the atlantic wire. The proof of heaven author has now been thoroughly. So before i read the article, i figured i had better read ebens book.
Oz, on larry king live, on oprah and on the cover of newsweek. The doctor whose story debunked proof of heaven esquire. Alexander claimed that much like the events fictionalized in the film flatliners, he experienced a detailed vision of. And his nde spouts a lot of mormon mysticism about the afterlife. Alexander goes to great lengths to make the case that his brain was completely nonfunctional during the days his near death experience happened. There is no indication in the book that it was laura potter, and not bacterial meningitis, that induced his coma, or that the physicians in the icu maintained his coma in the days that followed through the use of. Eben alexander proof of heaven investigation proof of heaven factual omissions esquire i read the book and dr. Commentary by nde researcher robert mays revised august 21, 20.
Hamilton, md, facs, author of the scalpel and the soul and zen mind, zen horse i can highly recommend this important book that has the potential to break many scientific taboos. Eben alexander debunked when eben alexanders book proof of heaven came out i initially found the story circulated by his publisher potentially compelling. However, when esquire contributing editor luke dittrich dug a bit deeper into dr. The article speaks for itself, and i urge you to read it. Eben alexander iii, a neurosurgeon, was attacked by a deadly form of meningitis. Page 1 esquire article on eben alexander distorts the facts.
Heres an excellent article by robert mays on esquires recent debunking of eben alexanders bestselling book proof of heaven. A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife be careful to not confuse neurosurgeon with neurologist or neuroscientist. I can highly recommend this important book that has the potential to break many scientific taboos. Alexander asserts that there is an eternity of perfect splendor awaiting us beyond the grave. Eben alexanders proof of heaven has been disproved. In heaven is for real, a child claims that while in a coma he hovered over his body, saw his family prayin g, and then went into heaven and met jesus the story is all narrated by his father. Dittrich cited several malpractice lawsuits against dr. An investigation by esquire magazine found all kinds of problems with alexanders tale, including his credibility. In july, 20, journalist luke dittrich wrote an article in esquire magazine critical of neurosurgeon eben alexanders 2012 book proof of heaven.
The author is a neurosurgeon who in 2008 fell victim to a rare form of bacterial meningitis that landed him in a weeklong coma. Esquires flimsy wall july 2, 20 esquires micropayment experiment by josh sternberg july 8, 20. When he awoke, he described having visited heaven a claim that led to a bestselling book. Its like the difference between an engineer and a scientist. The proof of heaven author has now been thoroughly debunked by science associated press july 2, 20. There is no indication in the book that it was laura potter, and. Read into those endorsements and nearly 15 million copies sold whatever you will, but in a big new esquire feature, luke dittrich pokes large holes in alexanders story, bringing into question the authors. Esquire article on eben alexander distorts the facts.
A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife, he asserts that he left his body and had a near death experience. In proof of heaven, alexander writes that he spent seven days in a coma caused by a rare case of e. Pim van lommel, cardiologist, author of consciousness beyond life. Interview with robert mays reveals a disturbing pattern of misrepresentation and distortion in luke dittrichs proof of heaven expose published in esquire magazine. Eben alexander rich and famous as a,man of science, whod experienced the afterlife, he was something else. It sold over two million copies and had been on the bestseller list for 35 weeks as of july 20. Proof of heaven author has multiple claims from his book debunked by doctor who treated him during his seven. A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife by eben alexander, m. Eben alexander proof of heaven investigation proof. Proof of heaven author debunked light, strange, activity. I have the pleasure of listening to the audiobook version read by the author. Eben alexander rich and famous as a man of science whod. A neurosurgeons journey into the afterlife 2012 describes his 2008 neardeath experience and asserts that science can and will determine that the brain does not create consciousness and that consciousness survives bodily death.